Skip to content
Mr. Cali Appraisals home
Request an appraisal
Call (909) 324-6122
All articles in Lending and Refinance Appraisals

Lending and Refinance AppraisalsBy Gordon Hall7 min read

Can a Refinance Be Denied After the Appraisal? What the Underwriter Reads in a Claremont Mortgage Report

Yes: the lender decides, using the appraised value and the report. What the underwriter reads in a Claremont report, and your Regulation B rights.

Empty living room with a wood-paneled fireplace wall and green tile hearth, recessed lights, a light wood-look floor and windows on both sides

Yes. A refinance can be restructured or denied after the appraisal, because the appraisal is one input to the lender's decision, not the decision itself. On a refinance the lender sets the loan-to-value ratio from the appraised value, and the underwriter reads the report for completeness, for how well the value is supported and for property issues the loan program cares about. The appraiser does not approve or deny loans; questions about credit, loan amount or eligibility belong to the lender.

This article explains what the underwriter reads in a Claremont mortgage report, what a lender must do when the report raises concerns, and the rights a borrower has to the report and to a reason for any denial.

Why can the appraisal change a refinance?

Because on a refinance there is no sales price to fall back on. For loans sold to Fannie Mae, Selling Guide section B2-1.2-01 (dated 06/01/2022) says that for a refinance "The property value is the current appraised value." That value is divided into the loan amount to produce the loan-to-value ratio, and the loan program sets the limits. If the ratio is outside what the program allows, the lender may offer different terms or decline the loan. Which of those happens is the lender's call.

A value is not the only thing that can matter. A report made "subject to" repairs or completion, a second unit whose legal status is unclear, or a property type the program does not accept can each hold up a loan even when the value is not in question.

What does the underwriter read in a Claremont report?

The underwriter reads the report from the subject facts to the conclusion. These are the parts that most often draw questions on Claremont houses.

  • Gross living area. The finished, above-grade living space, measured on site. On a Village Craftsman near the Colleges, enclosed porches and back rooms added decades ago often make the measured figure differ from public records, and the underwriter checks that the report explains the difference.
  • Condition and quality ratings. The report's standardized scores for upkeep and for construction quality. They need to match the photographs and the description.
  • Comparable selection. Whether the closed sales are the ones a buyer of this house would weigh. A Claraboya hillside home often needs comparables from a wider foothill band, and a postwar ranch is compared with other ranch tracts, not with the older blocks near the Village.
  • Adjustments. Whether each adjustment for size, condition, view or location is explained, including any Montclair or Upland sale used across the county line.
  • Reconciliation. The appraiser's weighing of the evidence into one opinion of value, and whether the conclusion follows from the analysis shown.
  • Additions and ADUs. Permit status for garage conversions on the tracts and for ADUs behind older houses, because it decides how the space is described.

Loans delivered to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac now carry these items in the redesigned Uniform Residential Appraisal Report, mandatory for new reports submitted on or after November 2, 2026. The room-by-room guide to a Claremont refinance appraisal shows how the facts are gathered, and the pillar guide to what the lender's form asks covers each section.

What must the lender do if the report raises concerns?

Fannie Mae's Selling Guide section B4-1.3-12, Appraisal Quality Matters (dated 09/03/2025), sets the steps for loans sold to Fannie Mae. The lender must confirm that appraisal reports are complete and that any changes are made by the original appraiser. If concerns raise questions about the reliability of the value, the lender must first try to resolve them with the original appraiser; if it cannot, it must obtain a replacement report before the final underwriting decision.

The lender may return the report with the deficiencies identified, obtain a desk or field review, or obtain a new appraisal. When it orders a new one, it must document the deficiencies and select the most reliable appraisal, not the one with the highest value. That last point matters to borrowers: a second report is not a second try at a number.

What rights does a borrower have?

Two federal rules apply on a first-lien mortgage application.

  • A copy of the appraisal. Regulation B, 12 CFR 1002.14, says a creditor "shall provide an applicant a copy of all appraisals and other written valuations" on an application for credit secured by a first lien on a dwelling, "promptly upon completion, or three business days prior to consummation of the transaction," whichever is earlier. The rule applies "whether credit is extended or denied or if the application is incomplete or withdrawn," and the creditor may not charge for providing the copy.
  • A reason for a denial. Regulation B, 12 CFR 1002.9, requires a written notice of adverse action that includes either "A statement of specific reasons for the action taken" or a disclosure of the right to such a statement, and says the statement of reasons "must be specific."

If the notice is unclear, ask the lender. Credit, debt and program questions are the lender's to answer, not the appraiser's.

Can I ask for the appraisal to be reconsidered?

Through the lender, yes. A reconsideration of value is, in the words of the 2024 interagency guidance from the federal banking agencies and the CFPB, "a request from a financial institution to the appraiser or other preparer" of the report "to reassess the report based upon potential deficiencies or other information that may affect the value conclusion."

For loans sold to Fannie Mae, Selling Guide B4-1.3-12 requires the lender to give the borrower a disclosure of the process with the report and says "only one borrower-initiated ROV is permitted per appraisal." The request can include "Additional data, information, or comparable properties (not to exceed five)," and "After a loan has closed, an ROV request is no longer allowed to be submitted by the borrower." The appraiser answers with a revised report that comments on the conclusion either way. Chase's borrower guidance describes the same route and asks borrowers not to contact the appraiser directly.

Useful requests are specific: a gross living area that missed a permitted addition, a bedroom left out, a closed Claremont sale from the same pocket that the report did not consider. An automated estimate such as a Zestimate, an agent's CMA and the county's assessed value are each not an appraisal and are not evidence for this purpose. How to write a reconsideration of value request covers the details, and the Claremont area page describes the pockets that comparables come from.

Next step

Lenders, credit unions and brokers who need a replacement or second report for a Claremont loan can order through residential appraisal for lending and refinance or call (909) 324-6122. The fee is set by the scope of the assignment, quoted before work begins and does not depend on the value. More in the series is on the lending and refinance appraisals hub, including how long a mortgage appraisal stays usable.

Sources

Gordon Hall, California Certified Residential Real Estate Appraiser, BREA No. AR003877 (lookup: https://www2.brea.ca.gov/breasearch/faces/party/view.xhtml?id=23601). Reports are prepared in conformity with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP). Nothing here is legal or tax advice; admissibility is always the court's decision.

Frequently asked questions

Can a refinance be denied after the appraisal?

Yes. On a refinance the lender uses the current appraised value for the loan-to-value ratio, and the underwriter also reads the report for completeness, support and property issues. If the loan falls outside the program, the lender may offer different terms or decline. The lender makes that decision, not the appraiser.

Do I get a copy of the appraisal if my refinance is denied?

Yes. Regulation B, 12 CFR 1002.14, requires the creditor to provide a copy of all appraisals and other written valuations on a first-lien dwelling application, and says the requirement applies whether credit is extended or denied or the application is incomplete or withdrawn. The creditor may not charge for the copy.

Will the lender tell me why the refinance was denied?

Regulation B, 12 CFR 1002.9, requires a written adverse action notice with either a statement of specific reasons or a disclosure of your right to one, and the reasons must be specific. Credit and program questions go to the lender.

Can I challenge the appraisal before the refinance is final?

Ask the lender for a reconsideration of value. For loans sold to Fannie Mae, one borrower-initiated request is permitted per appraisal, it may include up to five comparable properties with their data sources, and it cannot be submitted after the loan has closed.

Gordon Hall

Mr. Cali Appraisals

Call (909) 324-6122Contact

Keep reading